Code review comment for ~mertkirpici/juju-lint:lp/2009536

Revision history for this message
Gabriel Cocenza (gabrielcocenza) wrote :

>> Can rsyslog-forwarder-ha be deployed more than once in a machine?

> Yes. See discussion around hyperconverged architecture in lp #1855858 also the status file provided by the reporter for lp #2009536(also linked).

I've checked lp #1855858 and I didn't see rsyslog-forwarder-ha in the discussion. Just nrpe that is a special case. lp #2009536 there is also no comments if rsyslog-forwarder-ha could be deployed more than once in a machine.

That is why I think we should ask confirmation from Bootstack. Probably it's another special case because it makes sense to have it related with nova-compute and ceph-osd, but it would be good to confirm it just in case.

> Instead, this proposed solution completely discards the checks about duplicate existence of subordinates that are not declared as mandatory(in top level "subordinates" object).

What if we have a optional subordinate charm that shouldn't be duplicated? What is the behavior? We just don't check it? It doesn't looks good to me. Maybe we should differentiate optional principal charms from optional subordinate charms?

« Back to merge proposal