Code review comment for lp:~abreu-alexandre/webbrowser-app/window-open-overlay

Revision history for this message
Alexandre Abreu (abreu-alexandre) wrote :

> Not sure exactly what the intended UX behaviour is (the spec is a bit
> summary), this is what I’m seeing when testing on the desktop:
>
> - The animation to open an overlay is quite fast, almost imperceptible (could
> we maybe make it a tad slower?)

agree, done

> - When dismissing an overlay (by dragging it downwards or clicking on the
> chevron), it’s destroyed, right? I’m thinking that in that case maybe a cross
> icon would be more appropriate than a chevron, but of course that’s for a
> visual designer to decide.

yeah, those are the designs I had from "design", ... imo it is rather understandable,

> - When opening an overlay, the current webview seems to be hidden
> instantaneously, it should be hidden only once the animation has completed.
>
> - Similarly, when dragging an overlay downwards, nothing is visible behind, I
> think the main webview (or the previous overlay if any) should be visible.

I updated the behavior to be cleaner & slicker,

> - After opening 3 overlays, the fourth external link gets open in my desktop
> browser (chromium) as expected, but then after closing one overlay and
> starting to re-open more external links, I got in a situation where blank
> chromium windows would open instead of a new tab in the current instance, this
> is weird (tested with initially opening the container on
> http://plus.google.com). When that happens, I’m seeing the following message
> on the console:
>
> qml: Maximum number of popup overlay opened, opening: about:blank in the
> browser

mmh I was not able to repro that ...

« Back to merge proposal