Code review comment for lp:tomdroid/beta

Revision history for this message
Marnanel Thurman (marnanel) wrote :

My review based on the apk I downloaded last night (tested on an HTC phone):

1) THANK YOU. This will make my life a great deal easier.

2) I can't seem to edit the title of a newly-created note at all.

3) When I back out of editing a note, the "Discard Changes?" dialogue has two buttons, "Cancel" and "Yes". This is really rather confusing, because discarding the note is a cancelling action, yet pressing "Cancel" cancels the cancelling.

4) When I finish a sentence I'd rather like temporary shift to capitals as with other text areas. I don't know how easy this is, but I suspect it's just a flag somewhere.

5) The toolbar that pops out from the top right is probably unnecessary, since formatting in Tomboy notes is done inline.

6) Also, once the toolbar's been popped out, it can't be put back again. This is a nuisance, since it obscures the title.

7) I would prefer notes to be editable the moment you open them, rather than having to press a button (as it was in Conboy for Maemo, and as it is in Tomboy.)

8) The "save" option is really rather hard to find, buried in the actions menu.

9) Saving should be automatic as you type anyway, as in Conboy and Tomboy, rather than something you have to ask for. But if you don't do this, you should also have the option on the "discard changes?" dialogue of "no, save them".

I may come back and add more thoughts later, but this looks very promising. Thank you again.

« Back to merge proposal