Code review comment for lp:~brian-murray/ubuntu-community-accomplishments/check-bug-from-apport

Revision history for this message
Rafał Cieślak (rafalcieslak256) wrote :

Hello Brian, thanks for your MP!
As much as I like the fact that you have noticed that bugcontrol accomplishment has wrongly named script, I am unsure about checking only for bugs that were reported using apport. You are right that accomplishment's description suggests reporting them using `ubuntu-bug`, but I feel that restricting to bugs reported with this tool would be unfair for those who have filled reports via Launchpad. The accomplishment is 'Filed first bug' after all, and not 'Used ubuntu-bug'. The suggested steps for accomplishing this accomplishment are just one of many possible ways of 'reporting one's first bug'. Note that some people have already reported many bugs, but not a single one using ubuntu-bug, and would be confused why they are not getting this accomplishment. As far as I am concerned, I think we'd rather stick to looking for any bugs and not just apport ones, while suggesting to use ubuntu-bug in the description. It's meant to be a very general and basic accomplishment. It *might* be considered whether looking for only apport bugs isn't a good idea for a separate accomplishment, e.g. 'Report a bug using ubuntu-bug' (note that in many cases one would get both at once).

review: Abstain

« Back to merge proposal