Code review comment for lp:~blake-rouse/maas/osystem-registry

Revision history for this message
Julian Edwards (julian-edwards) wrote :

Thanks for all the fixes, it's looking much better. I'll mark it approved with some conditions as below as I know you're trying to get all this done for ODS.

I am not comfortable with leaving [4] only in trunk because there is always the risk that future SRUs/MREs will get rejected and then an LTS is stuck with code that won't work as required. However I think the risk is minimal here. Having said that, please do the RPC stuff in trunk as the simplest change that you can do and then it should backport cleanly to 1.5 as and when required.

For every fix that is being deferred, please file a bug with the description, tag it "tech-debt" and then refer to it with an XXX in the code like this:

   # XXX 2014-05-05 blake-rouse bug=NNNNNNN
   # Doing >blah< later.

So hopefully that means things won't get forgotten.

You didn't mention [9] in your response, are you willing to do that now or defer to a later branch? I think it's worth doing, the code will be much cleaner.

review: Approve

« Back to merge proposal