Ubuntu
dvdrip package

  1. Bug #478710
  2. Comment #12

Comment 12 for bug 478710

Revision history for this message
Luke J Militello (kilahurtz) wrote :

I've done the math and the actual rip process bails out at ~95% of the title length resulting in a none complete rip. This also leads me to believe dvd::rip is getting a false progress rate echoed back to it from the sub command called upon to do the actual rip or dvd::rip itself cannot compute the progress accurately. Either way, this is irrelevant and arbitrary to the problem at hand. As stated before, running the command from CLI yields the same results. On a test, I get the following echoed back to me after a ~95% completed rip.

[ ... ]
 1 109415 10138 10137 3731729 13
 1 109416 10138 10138 3731772 2
 1 109417 10138 10138 3731772 3
 2 0 0 0 3731840 0
--splitpipe-finished--
[tcscan] audio frames=215176.00, estimated clip length=8607.04 seconds
[tcscan] (min/max) amplitude=(-0.993/0.954), suggested volume rescale=1.007
[tcscan] V: 215176 frames, 8607 sec @ 25.000 fps
[tcscan] A: 131.33 MB @ 128 kbps
USER CDSIZE: 650 MB | V: 518.7 MB @ 493.7 kbps
USER CDSIZE: 700 MB | V: 568.7 MB @ 541.2 kbps
USER CDSIZE: 1300 MB | V: 1168.7 MB @ 1112.3 kbps
USER CDSIZE: 1400 MB | V: 1268.7 MB @ 1207.5 kbps
EXECFLOW_OK

And that is after executing the following command.

rm -f /opt/dvdrip/[SOME TITLE]/vob/001//[SOME TITLE]-???.vob && execflow -n 19 tccat -t dvd -T 1,-1,1 -i \/dev\/sr0 | dvdrip-splitpipe -f /opt/dvdrip/[SOME TITLE]/tmp/[SOME TITLE]-001-nav.log 1024 /opt/dvdrip/[SOME TITLE]/vob/001//[SOME TITLE] vob | tcextract -a 0 -x ac3 -t vob | tcdecode -x ac3 | tcscan -x pcm && echo EXECFLOW_OK

Also, this is where my dependencies sit as far as installed versions.

  Program Version
  -------------------------------
  dvd::rip 0.98.10
  transcode 1.1.4
  ImageMagick 6.5.1
  ffmpeg SVN-r19352-4:0.5+svn20090706-2ubuntu2,
  xvid4conf not installed
  subtitle2pgm 0.3
  lsdvd 0.16
  rar 3.90
  mplayer 4.4.1
  ogmtools 1.5
  dvdxchap 1.5
  mjpegtools 1.9.0
  xine 0.99.6
  fping 2.4
  hal 0.5.13
  -------------------------------

It would be really nice to get a response from someone just to know you are aware that this is a problem and possibly assist us in redirecting this bug to another team if it is determined a transcode issue or other dependent package. Waiting in silence is sort of frustrating.